The Fall 2026 Film Festival Circuit: Who's Showing, Who's Skipping, and What It Means for the Oscars
Werner Herzog plays all four festivals. The legacy studios play none. Here's how the 2026 awards season is shaping up — and what the fall festival lineup tells us about next year's Oscar race.
Our angle: This is one of several Bucket Movies pieces on the awards race. It focuses on the four fall festivals and what they suggest about the next Oscar race; the others are listed under Related coverage at the end.
Editor’s note (November 10, 2026): This analysis was first published on August 15. We have removed several errors and unsupported claims: Toronto has not dropped “International” from its name; we could not confirm that Bucking Fastard is the first film to pair Kate and Rooney Mara; Rooney Mara has made films since Nightmare Alley, including Women Talking; and we could not support the claim that the Academy has recently moved its ceremony earlier. Jonathan Glazer’s Joy of Joys is a documentary. Links to GoldDerby’s festival scorecard and IndieWire’s NYFF lineup report, which this piece draws on, have been added inline.
Update: At Venice, May El-Toukhy’s Woman Unknown won the Golden Lion (Venice record). At Toronto, La bola negra won the People’s Choice Award, with Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky and Being Heumann as runners-up (TIFF record).
Every year the fall festival circuit functions as a whispered audition for the Oscars. Venice, Telluride, Toronto, and the New York Film Festival don’t hand out Academy Awards, but they shape the narratives that eventually do. This year’s circuit is shaping up to be unusual — and the shape of it says more about where Hollywood is headed than any single movie does.
The four festivals occupy a strange position in the film industry calendar. They arrive after the summer blockbuster season winds down but before the holiday release corridor begins. For studios and streamers, they’re a proving ground. For filmmakers, they’re a marketplace. And for the rest of us, they’re the first signal of what the awards season will look like. The films that play well at these festivals don’t always win Oscars, but they almost always shape the conversation around who will.
The calendar: four festivals, one tight window
This year Venice ran September 2–12, Telluride September 4–7 over Labor Day weekend, Toronto September 10–20, and NYFF September 25–October 12 (GoldDerby). In practice, a film that plays Venice often hops to Telluride and Toronto within days. The logistics are exhausting, the jet lag is real, and the marketing value of that festival-to-festival momentum is enormous.
GoldDerby’s fall scorecard mapped twenty major awards contenders across those four venues (GoldDerby). Most play two or three. A handful play only one. And exactly one film is expected to play all four.
Bucking Fastard: the one film playing everywhere
Werner Herzog’s “Bucking Fastard” is the lone movie expected to appear at Venice, Telluride, Toronto, and NYFF. It stars sisters Kate and Rooney Mara. It’s Herzog’s first narrative feature since 2019, and at the time of GoldDerby’s scorecard it was still seeking U.S. distribution.
Playing all four festivals is both a badge of honor and a practical necessity for a film without a studio home. The visibility at each stop builds distribution leverage. If “Bucking Fastard” lands a strong review in Venice, that momentum carries into Telluride, where acquisition executives are already in town. By the time Toronto starts, a bidding war could be underway. Playing all four maximizes the chances of finding the right distributor — and the right price.
The Mara sisters are a draw on their own. Both have long-running careers in prestige film and television. A Herzog-directed film with both of them is the kind of package that makes festival programmers clear a slot.
The multi-festival strategy also serves a distribution purpose that goes beyond reviews. At Venice, the film gets its world premiere in front of an audience that skews toward art-house sensibilities. At Telluride, it screens for a smaller, more industry-focused crowd — the kind of people who write checks. At Toronto, the audience is the largest and most commercially minded of the four. At NYFF, the crowd is the New York critical establishment. Each audience tests a different aspect of the film’s potential. A movie that plays well across all four has demonstrated something rare: broad appeal without compromise.
The studios are staying home
Here’s the detail that should alarm anyone paying attention: according to GoldDerby, not one of the five remaining Hollywood legacy studios — Disney, Paramount, Sony, Universal, and Warner Bros. — was expected to bring any of its non-specialty-label awards contenders to the festival circuit this year.
This isn’t new, exactly. Studios have been gradually retreating from festivals for a decade. Netflix arrived to fill the gap, followed by Amazon, Apple, and other streamers. But the absence of the legacy studios’ main labels from the fall circuit is a milestone. It means the traditional pipeline — festival premiere, theatrical rollout, awards campaign — no longer runs through Venice or Toronto for the biggest players.
The studios’ strategy appears to be: skip the festival speculation cycle entirely, launch awards campaigns closer to voting, and use marketing spend to create the narrative instead of relying on festival reviews. Whether this works depends on whether the Academy’s voting body still responds to festival momentum or has shifted to pure marketing.
Warner Bros. was expected to follow the One Battle After Another playbook with Alejandro G. Iñárritu and Tom Cruise’s Digger, skipping the festivals. David Fincher’s “Cliff Booth” — a “Once Upon a Time in Hollywood” follow-up overseen by Netflix — was skipping them too, as were Aaron Sorkin’s “The Social Reckoning”, Laika’s “Wildwood” and a new “Sense and Sensibility” adaptation starring Daisy Edgar-Jones. These films will arrive directly in theaters or on streaming platforms, bypassing the festival gatekeepers altogether.
Netflix and the streaming contenders
The studios may be absent, but Netflix has a festival presence. “Cliff Booth” may be skipping the circuit, but Netflix’s Ink was set to travel from its Venice opening to Toronto, with a likely Telluride stop in between, a route Searchlight planned for Wild Horse Nine (GoldDerby).
The advantage Netflix has is straightforward: it can afford both festival acquisitions and long, expensive awards campaigns. Legacy studios are being more cautious. They’re playing the long game, and the fall festivals are their scouting combine.
The risk for Netflix is the same one they’ve always faced: their films often get strong reviews at festivals but struggle to convert that into Oscar wins. “The Power of the Dog” won Best Director. “Roma” and “Mank” and “The Irishman” all had festival momentum and Oscar nominations but fell short in the top categories. The question isn’t whether Netflix can acquire good films at festivals — they clearly can. The question is whether festival-acquired films can win Best Picture when the voting body still, at some level, values the theatrical experience.
The festival-to-streaming pipeline also creates an unusual dynamic for critics. When a film premieres at Venice and then drops on Netflix three weeks later, the critical conversation is compressed. There’s no slow build of word-of-mouth, no month-long theatrical run generating reviews and audience reactions. The film arrives on streaming with a burst of festival coverage, then competes for attention with whatever Netflix releases the following week. For awards purposes, this means a film needs to make its impression fast — and the festival circuit is where that impression begins.
The NYFF spotlight: Glazer, McCarthy, Duvernay
The New York Film Festival has quietly become the most interesting of the four major fall festivals. NYFF doesn’t chase acquisitions the way Toronto does, and it doesn’t have Venice’s glamour. What it has is curation — a programming team that consistently picks films for artistic merit over commercial potential.
This year’s NYFF Spotlight lineup includes several world premieres that suggest the festival is leaning into serious, idea-driven cinema. Jonathan Glazer’s new documentary “Joy of Joys” gets its world premiere at NYFF (IndieWire). Glazer’s last film, “The Zone of Interest,” won the Oscar for Best International Feature and was nominated for Best Picture. A documentary from Glazer will be one of the most scrutinized premieres of the fall.
Tom McCarthy’s “The Statement” (listed in the lineup as “A Statement”) is an environmental ensemble drama that also premieres at NYFF. McCarthy won Best Original Screenplay for “Spotlight” and has been selective about his projects since. An environmental theme puts the film in conversation with the cultural moment — climate anxiety has become a reliable awards-season topic, and McCarthy’s track record with ensemble casts suggests this won’t be a preachy polemic.
Ava DuVernay’s “14th” closes the festival. It’s a documentary follow-up to “13th,” exploring the origins and future of birthright citizenship. Duvernay’s “13th” was nominated for Best Documentary Feature and became a cultural touchstone. A sequel arriving in 2026, when immigration policy remains one of the most contentious issues in American politics, is guaranteed to generate conversation — whether that conversation translates into awards momentum depends on the documentary branch’s appetite for political films.
NYFF also includes Cristian Mungiu’s “Fjord,” which won the Palme d’Or at Cannes. Mungiu is one of the most respected filmmakers in European cinema, and “Fjord” arriving at NYFF after its Cannes triumph gives the festival a prestige anchor. Jordan Firstman’s “Club Kid” — his feature debut — also screens at NYFF, as does Albert Serra’s “Sixteen Moments of My Life”; James Gray’s Cannes competition title “Paper Tiger” opened the festival, suggesting the festival is willing to champion emerging voices alongside established masters.
What this means for the Oscar race
The fall festival circuit in 2026 tells a story about the industry’s shifting power dynamics. Legacy studios are retreating from the festival ecosystem. Streamers, led by Netflix, are filling the void. Independent distributors like A24 and Neon are still active at festivals but are no longer the only game in town.
For Oscar watchers, the practical implications are clear. The films that generate the most buzz at Venice and Toronto — the ones that critics call “must-see” and acquisition executives bid on — may not be the films that ultimately win. The studio system’s decision to bypass festivals suggests that the awards campaign playbook is being rewritten. Marketing, streaming availability, and voter outreach may matter more than festival reviews.
There’s also a precedent question. Last year, Paul Thomas Anderson skipped all four festivals and held the first screenings of One Battle After Another during TIFF, a route that ended in a Best Picture win (GoldDerby). That result is exactly why studios now feel comfortable bypassing the circuit.
But festivals still matter for one crucial reason: they create the narrative. Even if a film doesn’t win at the Oscars, a strong festival run gives it cultural relevance. “Nomadland” played Venice, Telluride, and Toronto before winning Best Picture. “Parasite” played Cannes and then Telluride before its historic Oscar sweep. The path from festival to Oscar isn’t guaranteed, but it remains the most reliable route for films that don’t have the marketing budgets of a Disney or a Warner Bros.
Werner Herzog’s “Bucking Fastard” playing all four festivals is the story of the season — a filmmaker who still believes in the circuit, backed by two of the most compelling actors working today, looking for a home. Whether that search ends with a distribution deal or an Oscar nomination, it’s the kind of story the fall festivals were built to tell.
How this was compiled: Festival dates, the contender map and the studio holdouts come from GoldDerby’s August 12 scorecard; the NYFF lineup from IndieWire; and festival results from the Venice and TIFF records as summarized on Wikipedia, all linked inline. See how we work.
Related coverage
More on the awards race:
- Sinners Makes Oscar History With Record 16 Nominations at the 2026 Academy Awards — the nominations for the 98th Academy Awards
- Telluride 2026: The World Premieres Already Shaping the Oscar Race — Telluride’s lineup and its early contenders
- Robert Pattinson’s Primetime and the Fall Festival Awards Picture — one acting contender: Robert Pattinson in Primetime
- Tom Cruise’s Oscar Push for Digger: Can the Campaign Overcome Split Reviews? — one campaign: Tom Cruise’s Best Actor push for Digger
Sources & further reading
- 1.
- 2. NYFF 2026 Spotlight Lineup — IndieWire
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
Venice 2026 Golden Lion Race: How the Festival Exceeded Its Weak Preview
How the 83rd Venice Film Festival turned a modest-looking lineup into a strong year, based on critics' reactions to its headline premieres.
Saturday Early Estimates for the November 20, 2026 Weekend
BoxOffice's Saturday list puts The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping at $120 million for November 20-22. The Numbers' Friday chart shows a $56 million opening day from 4,018 theaters and a wider field underneath.
November 13 Weekend Box Office Forecasts Across Six Wide Releases
Deadline's Friday update puts Ebenezer on a $20 million-plus pace after $7.1 million, with Cat in the Hat, Godzilla Minus Zero, and three other wide titles close behind.
Robert Pattinson's Primetime and the Fall Festival Awards Picture
Robert Pattinson's talk-show drama Primetime has emerged as an acting story of the fall festival season. What critics said and how it fits the awards race.




Loading comments...