Supergirl First Reactions: Critics Praise Milly Alcock, Split on the Film Around Her
Early reactions to DC Studios' Supergirl praised Milly Alcock and Jason Momoa's Lobo and compared the film's grimy tone to Mad Max, while others found it uneven. What critics said and what it means for the DCU.
The first social-media reactions to Supergirl, the second film in James Gunn and Peter Safran’s DC Universe, arrived on June 18, 2026, a week before its June 26 release. Directed by Craig Gillespie (I, Tonya, Cruella), the film stars Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El, with Jason Momoa as the bounty hunter Lobo and David Corenswet returning as Superman. Here is a summary of what critics said, drawn from roundups by Variety, Deadline, ComicBook.com and Rotten Tomatoes, followed by our own analysis.
A tone few expected
The most common observation was that Supergirl doesn’t look or feel like Gunn’s bright, optimistic Superman. Several critics compared it to Mad Max: Fury Road — dirty alien worlds, grotesque villains and a heroine with a self-destructive streak — while others added Guardians of the Galaxy and True Grit to the mix, describing an intergalactic road trip with a surprisingly sombre core. Film journalist Mike Ryan summed up the surprise: the film “looks and plays more like a ‘Mad Max’ movie.”
Milly Alcock wins over critics
Alcock, best known for House of the Dragon, received the most consistent praise. Reactions highlighted her humour, emotional range and the way she plays Kara as jaded and abrasive rather than as a copy of her cousin — a deliberate contrast with Superman’s earnestness. Even critics who were lukewarm on the film singled her out.
Momoa’s Lobo: a crowd-pleaser
Jason Momoa’s casting as Lobo, the foul-mouthed space mercenary from the comics, had been anticipated for years, and early reactions suggested it paid off. Critics described him as having enormous fun in the role, though some, including The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney in the full reviews, felt the character was underused.
The reservations
Not everyone was won over. Some critics called the film a “mixed bag,” citing a bland villain and adaptation choices that diverge from the comics; others felt it took too long to get going. When full reviews arrived on June 24, Rotten Tomatoes’ roundup characterised it as an uneven entry lifted by a superb lead. Germain Lussier of io9 offered a middle view: enjoyable, emotional, and a good companion to Superman, though without that film’s resonance.
Our analysis: what the reactions tell us
Early social-media reactions skew positive — they come largely from press screenings and fan-friendly outlets — so the split here was notable. The pattern of the comments points to a familiar problem for superhero films: a strong central performance carrying a story that doesn’t fully support it.
The tonal shift is also a strategic choice. Gunn’s DC Universe is trying to avoid the sameness that critics increasingly associate with Marvel’s output. Letting Gillespie make a grittier, more melancholy film is a bet that variety is more valuable than consistency. Supergirl tests whether audiences will follow a lesser-known hero into an unfamiliar tone — a test that the R-rated Clayface would push further in October.
The comic-book source
The film draws on Tom King and Bilquis Evely’s comic Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow (2021–2022), an eight-issue series in which Kara Zor-El, who remembers Krypton’s destruction, travels across space with a young alien girl seeking revenge. Critics praised it for presenting Kara as more world-weary and complex than her cousin. James Gunn cited the comic as an inspiration when announcing the film in 2023.
Earlier versions of Supergirl
- Supergirl (1984), starring Helen Slater with Faye Dunaway and Peter O’Toole, was a critical and commercial failure.
- Supergirl (CBS/The CW, 2015–2021) starred Melissa Benoist across six seasons and was popular with fans.
- The Flash (2023) featured Sasha Calle as a version of Kara.
The filmmakers
Craig Gillespie directed Lars and the Real Girl (2007), I, Tonya (2017), which won Allison Janney the Supporting Actress Oscar, and Disney’s Cruella (2021). Milly Alcock broke out playing young Rhaenyra Targaryen in HBO’s House of the Dragon (2022). Jason Momoa, who plays Lobo, previously played Aquaman in the DCEU.
Who it suits
Fans of the comics and of Gunn’s Superman will find the most to enjoy. Viewers who prefer grounded superhero films may find the space setting and Lobo’s comic tone a change of pace. Check your usual digital storefronts or streaming services for its current availability.
How to read social-media reactions
First reactions, posted after press screenings, are a limited guide to a film’s quality. They come from critics and journalists invited to early screenings, are written immediately afterwards, and tend to be more enthusiastic than full reviews published later. Studios typically lift the social embargo days before the review embargo. A better guide is the critical consensus after reviews are published, along with audience measures such as CinemaScore, which surveys moviegoers on opening night.
For Supergirl, the gap between social reactions and full reviews is worth comparing with other DC films: Superman (2025) received largely positive reviews, while earlier DCEU films such as Batman v Superman (2016) had strong social reactions followed by harsh reviews.
Where Supergirl fits in the DC Universe
DC Studios’ slate opened with the animated series Creature Commandos (2024), followed by Superman (2025) and season two of Peacemaker (2025). Supergirl is the second feature film in the shared universe, with Clayface following in October 2026. Viewers new to the universe can watch Supergirl on its own, though Superman introduces Milly Alcock’s Kara in a brief appearance.
Update: how it performed
Supergirl opened on June 26 to $37.1 million domestically and finished with $72.4 million in North America and $126.5 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo. Its final score on Rotten Tomatoes is 52%, consistent with the split in the first reactions described above.
The comparison with Superman is stark. Gunn’s 2025 film opened to $125.0 million domestically and earned $618.7 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo, almost five times Supergirl’s total.
| Superman (2025) | Supergirl (2026) | |
|---|---|---|
| Domestic opening | $125.0 million | $37.1 million |
| Domestic total | $354.2 million | $72.4 million |
| Worldwide total | $618.7 million | $126.5 million |
| Domestic share of total | 57.3% | 57.2% |
Two details stand out. First, Supergirl’s domestic total was less than twice its opening weekend, a sign of weak word of mouth, which fits the mixed reviews. Second, the split between domestic and international earnings was almost identical for both films. Supergirl did not lose international audiences in particular; it drew fewer people everywhere.
What it means for the DCU
The first reactions predicted the core problem: a well-liked lead in a film many critics found uneven. The box office confirmed that a lesser-known hero, an unfamiliar tone and mixed reviews were too much to overcome, even with Superman’s own success the previous summer. DC’s next release, Clayface in October, took a different approach as a mid-budget, R-rated horror film, and opened at No. 1 with about $24.5 million; see our Clayface box office analysis. For more on how DC’s 2026 slate fared, see our midyear box office analysis.
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
Clayface Box Office: DC's $24.5 Million Horror Experiment, Explained
Clayface opened at No. 1 with about $24.5 million in North America and $43 million worldwide. How the weekend unfolded, how it compares with DC and horror openings, and what the holds since then say about DC's mid-budget gamble.
Venice 2026 Lineup: Boyle, Herzog, and a Murdoch Biopic Open the Most Political Festival in Years
Danny Boyle's Rupert Murdoch drama opens Venice as the festival unveils a competition stacked with auteurs, a single female director, and a sharp political edge.
Nuisance Bear Is in Theaters After Its Critics Choice Win as Josephine Sets November 20
Nonfics says Nuisance Bear is in theaters after the Critics Choice science and nature prize. Josephine, a Sundance double prize winner, is dated for select theaters on November 20.
Cliff Booth Trailer: Fincher, Tarantino, and IMAX Details
Netflix released the official Cliff Booth trailer for David Fincher and Quentin Tarantino's 1977 neo-noir, confirming a 141-minute runtime and IMAX dates.




Loading comments...