I Want Your Sex Review Roundup: What Critics Said About Gregg Araki's Erotic Comedy
Gregg Araki's I Want Your Sex, with Olivia Wilde and Cooper Hoffman, drew strong reviews out of Sundance and a small theatrical gross. What critics praised, their reservations, how it was made and who it is for.
Editor’s note: This review is a roundup of published critical reception and reporting, with analysis by the Bucket Movies Editorial Team. We did not attend a screening; plot and scene details are summarized from published reviews and official materials. See how we work.
Editor’s note: an earlier version of this article described scenes in detail and offered judgments that were not tied to any published source. It has been rewritten from the published reviews and reporting linked below.
Our angle: I Want Your Sex is Gregg Araki’s first feature in more than a decade. Nearly every review read it through two lenses: his career, and the recent run of age-gap and power-play films such as Babygirl. This roundup sets out what critics said, where they split, and why a well-reviewed film found such a small audience in theaters.
What the film is
I Want Your Sex is a 2026 erotic comedy thriller directed by Gregg Araki (Mysterious Skin, The Doom Generation, Kaboom), who co-wrote it with Karley Sciortino. Olivia Wilde plays Erika Tracy, a famous provocative artist, and Cooper Hoffman plays Elliot, the 23-year-old assistant who becomes her lover. Mason Gooding, Chase Sui Wonders, Charli XCX, Daveed Diggs and Roxane Mesquida co-star, with Johnny Knoxville and Margaret Cho as the police detectives. Araki produced it with Seth Caplan, Teddy Schwarzman, Michael Heimler, Courtney L. Cunniff and Sciortino, and co-edited it with Victor de la Parra. Charli XCX plays Minerva, Elliot’s graduate-student girlfriend. The film runs 90 minutes. It premiered at the Sundance Film Festival on January 23, 2026, and Magnolia Pictures released it in U.S. theaters on July 31. Deadline’s review notes that it has no connection to the George Michael song of the same name.
The premise (no ending)
The film opens with Elliot finding Erika floating unconscious in her pool, then flashes back “nine-and-a-half weeks.” Struggling and unemployed, Elliot takes a job in Erika’s studio helping produce her sexually explicit art. He soon enters a dominant-submissive relationship with her, despite a warning from her business manager, Vikktor (Diggs), that he is neither her first partner nor her last. Those flashbacks alternate with Elliot’s police interrogation. The plot has several turns after that, which we will not spoil.
How it was made
- Development. The project was first reported in May 2024 with Wilde attached. Hoffman and Charli XCX joined that August, and Diggs, Gooding, Wonders, Knoxville and Cho followed in October.
- The gender flip. The screenplay originally centered on a young woman and her older male boss. Araki and Sciortino, the writer known for the sex-and-culture platform Slutever, reversed the genders when they revisited it years later.
- Casting Hoffman. Araki has said he was unsure about Hoffman at first because he associated him with Licorice Pizza. A self-taped audition and a chemistry read with Wilde changed his mind.
- The shoot. Filming took place in Los Angeles from October 2 to 27, 2024, with Tucker Korte as cinematographer and James Clements composing the score. Black Bear Pictures produced.
- The sale. Magnolia acquired U.S. rights in February 2026, ahead of a summer theatrical release.
What critics praised
Rotten Tomatoes lists 92% approval from more than 160 reviews. Its consensus calls the film “one of indie stalwart Gregg Araki’s most accessible works yet.” Metacritic shows 67 from 39 critics, which it classifies as “generally favorable.” The gap between the two figures is typical of a film that most critics liked but few called a masterpiece.
- The performances. David Rooney of The Hollywood Reporter called it “easily one of [Wilde’s] best roles.” He wrote that the “equally fearless” Hoffman matched her “with sly comic timing and poignant vulnerability,” and that the movie “is a blast,” showing that Araki “has lost none of his youthful spark.”
- The tone. Deadline’s review called it Araki’s “gender-reversed Sunset Boulevard” and a “campy, ridiculous, raunchy comedy” aimed at Gen Z. It also wrote: “Imagine if Babygirl had been fun.” Deadline added that, beneath the provocations, the film is “surprisingly relatable at its core.”
- The return. TheWrap called it a “triumphant return” that proves Araki “has not lost his edge.” It described the film as “sexy, it’s silly, it’s sinister and it’s just serious enough,” and singled out “one of the best turns from Hoffman to date.”
Reservations
The reviews that held back focused on the plot and the film’s depth rather than its performances.
- Variety compared Wilde’s character to James Spader’s boss in Secretary. It wrote that the film is “fully liberated where sex and nudity are concerned, but kind of old-fashioned” in its interpersonal dynamics, and that “once you get past the shock, the plot falls apart.” It concluded that there is “no important message or perceptive social insight” to take from it, and suggested treating it as “pure, irreverent escapism.”
- Benjamin Lee of The Guardian headlined his review “vampy Olivia Wilde almost saves Gregg Araki’s tame dom-sub romp.” He praised Wilde’s “magnetically old school femme fatale pull” but concluded that Araki has “not that much” to say about the current moment.
- Even positive reviews flagged structural problems. TheWrap mentioned “structural narrative cheats,” and The Hollywood Reporter said it “threatens to run out of steam” late on.
The pattern is consistent: near-universal praise for Wilde and Hoffman, and disagreement over whether the film’s provocations add up to an argument or are simply fun.
The age-gap context
The film arrived during a wave of stories about older women and younger men. Co-writer Sciortino addressed that directly in an essay for Vogue. She listed Babygirl, The Idea of You, Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy, Vladimir and Marty Supreme as recent examples, and wrote that the older woman/younger man dynamic is “extremely hot in Hollywood—and with audiences.” She also argued that beneath “all the discourse about age gaps and boy toys and the female gaze,” the film is “about a young person having a heart-wrenching, eye-opening sexual experience that changes them forever.”
That is useful context for the reviews. Deadline’s “Imagine if Babygirl had been fun” reads the film as a lighter take on the same trend. Variety’s comparison to Secretary points back to an earlier BDSM workplace comedy that also premiered at Sundance. Critics were judging the film partly against its neighbors, and on that measure most found it the more playful option.
Box office
Magnolia released the film in U.S. theaters on July 31. It grossed about $1.48 million domestically and $2.45 million worldwide, per Box Office Mojo. That is a small total even for a specialty release. Its strong reviews did not translate into theatrical attendance, perhaps unsurprisingly for an explicit, adults-only comedy opening in the middle of summer blockbuster season. Festival screenings followed in Sydney and at the Edinburgh International Film Festival, where it had its U.K. premiere in August.
Where it sits in Araki’s career
Araki made his name in the 1990s with the “Teen Apocalypse Trilogy” (Totally F**ed Up*, The Doom Generation and Nowhere). His best-known film, Mysterious Skin (2004), was a drama. Kaboom (2010) was his last feature before a long run directing television. Deadline and The Guardian both measured the new film against Kaboom, his last trip into this kind of kitschy, sex-comedy territory. The Hollywood Reporter framed it as Araki reaching a generation that was not born when the trilogy came out. That framing helps explain the split. Critics who wanted the old Araki energy got it, while critics who wanted a sharper statement about sex and power in 2026 found it thinner.
Who it is for
The reviews suggest a clear audience. Viewers who enjoy campy, explicit comedy and Araki’s earlier films will likely have a good time, and anyone curious about Wilde’s or Hoffman’s range has a strong reason to watch. Viewers looking for a serious study of power and consent, or who are uncomfortable with frank sexual content, may side with Variety and The Guardian. This is an adults-only film with frequent, explicit sexual content. For more of this summer’s smaller releases, see our late-August 2026 watch list and most anticipated indie films of 2026, or browse the reviews section.
Our read
Read together, the reviews describe a confident, funny, deliberately provocative comeback that critics enjoyed more than they admired. The performances are the strongest consensus point. The most common complaint is that the plot depends on convenient turns and that the satire does not cut very deep. For a filmmaker whose career has been built on fun with an edge, most reviewers seemed content with the trade.
How this was compiled: credits, plot outline, production and release details come from Magnolia Pictures and Sundance materials and the trade coverage linked above; critics’ quotes come from the linked reviews in The Hollywood Reporter, Deadline, TheWrap, Variety and The Guardian; scores are from Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic; box office from Box Office Mojo. Bucket Movies did not watch the film for this piece. See how we work.
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
'The Dink' Review: Ben Stiller and Jake Johnson Serve Up the Year's Most Surprisingly Charming Sports Comedy
Apple TV+'s pickleball comedy shouldn't work — a 103-minute film about the world's most ridiculed sport, starring a guy who looks perpetually confused. Yet 'The Dink' lands its shots more often than it misses, thanks to a game cast and a script that knows exactly how silly its premise is.
Moana (2026) Review Roundup: Critics Call Disney's Live-Action Remake Its Most Faithful, and Most Pointless
Disney's live-action Moana arrived just ten years after the original. What critics said, who stars, how it was made, why it lost money and where to stream it, with every source linked.
Anora Review: Sean Baker's Unflinching Masterpiece of Class, Desire, and the American Dream
Sean Baker's Anora, the Palme d'Or and Best Picture winner, is a screwball fairy tale about a Brooklyn stripper who marries an oligarch's son. What critics praised, where they pushed back, and how it was made.
The Furious Review Roundup: Why Critics Called Kenji Tanigaki's Action Film the Year's Best Fighting
Kenji Tanigaki's The Furious, starring Xie Miao and Joe Taslim, drew near-unanimous praise for its fight choreography and some complaints about its plot. What critics said, how it was made and how it performed.




Loading comments...