Moana (2026) official poster
Moana (2026) official poster
Review 8 min read ✓ seen it!

Moana (2026) Review Roundup: Critics Call Disney's Live-Action Remake Its Most Faithful, and Most Pointless

Disney's live-action Moana arrived just ten years after the original. What critics said, who stars, how it was made, why it lost money and where to stream it, with every source linked.

By Bucket Movies Editorial Team

Editor’s note: This review is a roundup of published critical reception and reporting, with analysis by the Bucket Movies Editorial Team. We did not attend a screening; plot and scene details are summarized from published reviews and official materials. See how we work.

Editor’s note: an earlier version of this article misnamed the film’s new song and described scenes that could not be verified. It has been rewritten from the published reviews and reporting linked below.

Our angle: the live-action Moana reached theaters just under ten years after the animated film. That is a far shorter gap than for The Lion King or The Little Mermaid, and almost every published review returned to the same question: what is a remake for when the original is still so fresh? This roundup collects the answers.

What Moana (2026) is

Moana is a live-action musical adaptation of Disney Animation’s 2016 film and the third film in the Moana franchise, after Moana 2 (2024). It is directed by Thomas Kail, making his narrative feature debut after directing the filmed version of Hamilton (2020), and written by Jared Bush and Dana Ledoux Miller. Dwayne Johnson, Hiram Garcia, Dany Garcia, Beau Flynn and Lin-Manuel Miranda produced. Walt Disney Studios released it in the U.S. on July 10, 2026. It runs 115 minutes and cost a reported $250 million, making it one of the most expensive films ever made.

Cast:

  • Catherine Laga’aia as Moana, in her film debut.
  • Dwayne Johnson as Maui, reprising his role from the animated films.
  • Rena Owen as Gramma Tala.
  • John Tui as Chief Tui, Moana’s father.
  • Frankie Adams as Sina, Moana’s mother.
  • Jemaine Clement as the voice of Tamatoa, the treasure-hoarding coconut crab, also reprising his role.

The story

The story follows the 2016 original closely. On the island of Motunui, a blight kills crops and empties the fishing grounds. Moana, the chief’s daughter, has been chosen by the ocean to return the stolen heart of the island goddess Te Fiti. Her grandmother, Tala, reveals that their people were once voyagers, and Moana sails beyond the reef to find the demigod Maui and set things right. Critics’ main complaint was how little this version changes.

How it was made

According to the production history, Disney first approached Johnson privately about a remake in 2019, and he announced it publicly in April 2023. Kail was named director that May. The SAG-AFTRA strike delayed casting, and Laga’aia was announced in June 2024 alongside Tui, Adams and Owen. Filming ran from July 29, 2024, in Atlanta, under the working title Canon, to November 22 in Hawaii. Óscar Faura was cinematographer, and Bill Westenhofer left Captain America: Brave New World to supervise the visual effects.

One reported plan was abandoned. In August 2025, it emerged that the studio had considered using an AI-generated likeness of Johnson’s face on a body double for some shots, with his approval and help from the company Metaphysic. The idea was dropped to avoid controversy.

Musically, Mark Mancina returned to score, and Opetaia Foa’i’s songs return. Miranda, who wrote songs for the original but missed Moana 2 because of Mufasa: The Lion King, came back and wrote one new song, “Along the Way.” Its end-credits version is performed by Auli’i Cravalho, the original voice of Moana, with Laga’aia and Johnson. Johnson and his wife, Lauren Hashian, also executive produced Moana: Voices Across the Ocean, a companion album of Pacific Island artists, released July 31, 2026.

How short the gap is

Disney’s earlier live-action remakes generally waited decades. The gap for Moana is the shortest so far:

Animated originalYearLive-action remakeYearGap
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs1937Snow White202588 years
The Little Mermaid1989The Little Mermaid202334 years
Beauty and the Beast1991Beauty and the Beast201726 years
The Lion King1994The Lion King201925 years
Lilo & Stitch2002Lilo & Stitch202523 years
Moana2016Moana202610 years

That timing explains much of the criticism. The original remains one of the most-streamed films on Disney+, as D’Amaro himself noted, and Moana 2 had passed $1 billion at the box office only 18 months earlier. Many children in the target audience had seen the animated version recently, often more than once. A near-identical remake therefore asked families to pay for a story they could stream at home, a point The Playlist’s Marshall Shaffer made pointedly, as quoted below. Lilo & Stitch, by contrast, became a hit in 2025 after a 23-year gap; the distance from the original may be one factor.

What critics said

The reviews were among the worst for any Disney live-action remake. Rotten Tomatoes reports a 33% approval rating from about 200 reviews, with the consensus: “The sea calls to no one in this underwhelming new version of Moana, a rather lifeless endeavor that solidifies its animated predecessor as the superior adventure.” Metacritic shows 42.

The central criticism was faithfulness:

  • Tasha Robinson of Polygon wrote that “virtually every line, beat, and song in the new movie is identical to the 2016 version,” concluding: “There’s no artistic or aesthetic reason for this movie to exist.”
  • Wilson Chapman of IndieWire called it “the most faithful any Disney remake has ever been,” comparable in precision to “a shot-for-shot facsimile on par with Gus Van Sant’s Psycho.”
  • Jonathan Romney of The Observer called it “an unimaginatively faithful remake” in which replacing animated characters with live actors “manages to ramp up the folkloric kitsch considerably.”
  • Alissa Wilkinson of The New York Times called it “the most pointless, and perhaps not accidentally, the worst” of all of Disney’s live-action remakes.

Some reviews were harsher about the craft. Clarisse Loughrey gave it one star out of five in The Independent, writing that “Dwayne Johnson’s terrible wig is just one low point of a film that has all the visual allure of a Febreze advert.” Marshall Shaffer of The Playlist predicted it was “destined for great viewership in households that accidentally click the wrong title on the service.”

The kindest major review came from Liz Shannon Miller of Consequence, who gave it a B−. She noted that it “contains no nightmare fuel on the level of 2025’s Snow White—which ends up being high praise for adaptations like these.”

What audiences said

Audiences were kinder: opening-weekend moviegoers gave it an “A−” CinemaScore. That pattern, a good grade from those who chose to go but weak turnout overall, matches other recent Disney remakes.

The box office

Tracking pointed to a $60 million to $65 million domestic opening. The film instead opened to $43 million in the U.S. and Canada and $95 million worldwide, per Deadline. That is below Dumbo’s $46 million in 2019, though above Snow White’s $42.2 million in 2025. Deadline estimated the studio could lose $100 million to $125 million. It went on to gross about $126 million domestically and $324 million worldwide, per Box Office Mojo, against a $250 million budget.

Disney’s leadership offered explanations. CEO Josh D’Amaro said the film missed expectations but helped merchandise and theme parks. Dana Walden, Disney’s president and chief creative officer, blamed the timing: it arrived only 18 months after Moana 2. Trade coverage also cited remake fatigue and a crowded summer that included Disney’s own Toy Story 5 (see our roundup).

Where to watch

Moana was released digitally on September 8, 2026, and on 4K Ultra HD, Blu-ray and DVD on October 6. It began streaming on Disney+ on October 21, 2026, alongside the 2016 original and Moana 2. At home, it did better than in theaters: it topped the U.K. Official Film Chart and Fandango at Home’s weekly chart after its digital release.

Our read of the reviews

The reviews give a clear answer to the question the film raises. Nearly every critic found it a careful copy of a film that did not need copying, and few singled out anything it adds. Families whose children want to see a real-world version of Motunui may still enjoy it. Everyone else is likely to get more from rewatching the 2016 film, which streams in the same place. For another 2026 family release, see our Minions & Monsters roundup.

How this was compiled: credits, plot outline, production details and release dates come from Disney materials and trade reporting; critics’ quotes come from the linked reviews in Polygon, IndieWire, The Independent, The Playlist and Consequence, plus The Observer and The New York Times; scores are from Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic and CinemaScore; box office figures from Deadline, Variety and Box Office Mojo. Bucket Movies did not watch the film for this piece. See how we work.

Filed under #Disney #Live-Action Remake #Moana #Dwayne Johnson #Fantasy #2026 Movies
Pass it on a friend needs this film
0 reads0 comments

worth a spot on the list?

Reader notes

Join the discussion

No account needed — leave your take on this film below.

0/1000

Loading comments...

Up next

Add these to your list

More review