A Minecraft Movie Review Roundup: Critics Shrugged, Audiences Shouted 'Chicken Jockey'
Jared Hess's A Minecraft Movie drew mixed reviews and became a $961 million hit and a theater phenomenon. What critics said, who plays whom, how it was made, and the sequel.
Editor’s note: This review is a roundup of published critical reception and reporting, with analysis by the Bucket Movies Editorial Team. We did not attend a screening; plot and scene details are summarized from published reviews and official materials. See how we work.
Editor’s note: an earlier version of this article misdescribed the main characters and villain and included technical claims that could not be verified. It has been rewritten from the published reviews and reporting linked below.
Our angle: few recent films show a wider gap between critics and audiences than A Minecraft Movie. Critics gave it a 47% on Rotten Tomatoes, while audiences turned it into a $961 million hit and a noisy communal event. This roundup takes both sides seriously.
What A Minecraft Movie is
A Minecraft Movie is a 2025 live-action fantasy comedy based on Mojang’s sandbox game, directed by Jared Hess (Napoleon Dynamite, Nacho Libre). The screenplay is credited to Chris Bowman, Hubbel Palmer, Neil Widener, Gavin James and Chris Galletta, from a story by Allison Schroeder, Bowman and Palmer. Warner Bros. and Legendary released it on April 4, 2025, after a London premiere on March 30. It runs 101 minutes and was made for a reported $150 million.
The cast as credited:
- Jason Momoa: Garrett “The Garbage Man” Garrison, a 1980s video game champion who now runs a struggling game store in Chuglass, Idaho.
- Jack Black: Steve, a former doorknob salesman who has spent years in the Overworld.
- Emma Myers: Natalie, who becomes her younger brother’s legal guardian after their mother’s death.
- Sebastian Hansen: Henry, her inventive younger brother.
- Danielle Brooks: Dawn, a real estate agent who runs a mobile petting zoo.
- Jennifer Coolidge: Marlene, the vice principal of Chuglass High School.
- Rachel House: the voice of Malgosha, the piglin ruler of the Nether.
The premise
Henry and Natalie move to Chuglass after their mother dies. Henry, in trouble at school on his first day, pays Garrett to pose as his uncle. In Garrett’s shop he finds two artifacts, the Orb of Dominance and the Earth Crystal, which Garrett bought at a storage auction of Steve’s old belongings. Combined, they open a portal, and Henry, Garrett, Natalie and Dawn are pulled into the Overworld, a world made entirely of cubes. There they meet Steve, who teaches them to craft and build while Malgosha, who hates creativity, hunts for the orb.
The film’s makers chose the title A Minecraft Movie, rather than The Minecraft Movie, to signal that it tells one story set in Minecraft rather than an official canon. For the same reason, Black’s Steve is presented as one of many possible Steves rather than the game’s default character.
A decade in development
The film took more than eight years to reach production. Mojang said in February 2014 that it was in talks with Warner Bros., and Shawn Levy was attached to direct later that year before leaving by December. Rob McElhenney took over in 2015 with a preliminary $150 million budget and a planned May 2019 release, but his version “slowly died on the vine” after a change of studio leadership in 2016. Peter Sollett was hired in 2019 to write and direct an entirely different story. His version reportedly followed a teenage girl and her group of adventurers on a quest to defeat the Ender Dragon, the game’s final boss, and it was dropped during the pandemic.
In April 2022, the project restarted with Hess directing, Legendary co-producing and Momoa in talks to star. Hess’s Masterminds (2016) collaborators Chris Bowman and Hubbel Palmer were brought in to rewrite. Producer Roy Lee credited new Warner Bros. leadership, Pam Abdy and Mike De Luca, with reviving it. Hess said he enjoyed trying to “adapt something that doesn’t have a story—it’s an open sandbox game.” The long road explains the unusually long credits list. More than 20 other writers received off-screen “additional literary material” credit, among them McElhenney, Sollett, Zak Penn and John Francis Daley.
How it was made
- Casting changes. Matt Berry was originally set to play Steve, with Black cast only as a talking pig. The 2023 strikes forced Berry out, and Black took the lead. Berry still voices a villager.
- Location. Filming ran from January to April 2024 around Auckland, New Zealand. The town of Huntly stood in for Chuglass, Idaho.
- Effects. The production used Unreal Engine to build virtual versions of sets. Sony Pictures Imageworks, Wētā FX and Digital Domain provided the visual effects, and the crew kept every in-world object, down to trees and fruit, made of cubes.
- Music. Mark Mothersbaugh composed the score with “nods” to C418’s game music. Black’s song “Steve’s Lava Chicken” became the shortest song ever to enter the Billboard Hot 100, and also reached the U.K. Top 40.
Cameos for players
The film includes several nods aimed at the game’s community. YouTubers DanTDM, Aphmau, Mumbo Jumbo and LDShadowLady appear as auction attendees; Mumbo Jumbo also helped design props. Jens Bergensten, one of Minecraft’s lead designers, cameos as a waiter, and Kate McKinnon has an uncredited voice cameo in a post-credits scene as Alex.
What critics praised
The performances drew the most praise, especially Black and Momoa. Several critics saw them as the main reason to watch. Liz Shannon Miller of Consequence argued that the story was not the point and that the film was made mainly to have fun, and she found the plot easy to follow even without knowing the game. Some reviewers also appreciated the fan service, particularly a tribute to the late YouTuber Technoblade: a pig wearing a crown.
Clarisse Loughrey of The Independent thought a live-action Minecraft was a flawed idea in principle, but credited the film with “genuine intent.” In her view, it was not one of the adaptations that exist only to make money.
Where critics pushed back
The aggregate scores are low. Rotten Tomatoes lists 47% from about 200 reviews, with a consensus that the film “provides a colorful sandbox for Jack Black and Jason Momoa” but tells a story “curiously constructed from conventional building blocks.” Metacritic shows 45, indicating “mixed or average” reviews.
Lovia Gyarkye of The Hollywood Reporter felt the film struggled to balance pleasing the fandom with making sense to a general audience. Jesse Hassenger of IGN called it “conceptually muddy” and “confusingly and erratically presented.” The harshest critics treated it as a brand extension. David Fear of Rolling Stone likened it to a corporate cash grab, and Kevin Maher of The Times made a similar argument. Other reviewers found the subplot in which Coolidge’s vice principal dates a villager thin or unnecessary, although some enjoyed it anyway.
What audiences thought
Audiences were much warmer. Opening-weekend audiences gave it a “B+” CinemaScore, and in PostTrak polling, children under 12 rated it five stars out of five, with parents at four and a half.
Then came the “chicken jockey” trend. Teenage audiences, mostly boys, began cheering, throwing popcorn and jumping up at lines that had become memes, especially Steve’s shout of “Chicken jockey!” The Guardian reported on cinemas struggling with disruptive screenings, and some chains posted behaviour warnings. In one widely shared case, a viewer in Provo, Utah, brought a live chicken. Hess told Entertainment Weekly that he and Black thought it “would be funny if Steve announced everything that happens to him.” Warner Bros. eventually leaned in with a “Block Party Edition” sing-along release on May 2, 2025. Commentators compared the phenomenon to audience participation at The Rocky Horror Picture Show and The Room.
Box office
The film opened to $162.8 million domestically and $313 million worldwide. That was the biggest opening ever for a video game adaptation, ahead of The Super Mario Bros. Movie, which also starred Black. It finished with $424.1 million in the U.S. and Canada and $961.2 million worldwide, per Box Office Mojo. That made it the fifth-highest-grossing film of 2025 and the third-highest-grossing video game film of all time.
The sequel
On October 9, 2025, Warner Bros. and Legendary announced a sequel for July 23, 2027, with Hess returning to direct and Galletta co-writing.
Who it is for
The split verdict makes the choice simple. Families with children who play Minecraft are the audience the film was built for, and the polling suggests they got what they wanted. Adults who want a coherent story may side with the critics. Fans of Black’s comedy, or of the communal madness of a packed opening weekend, will find the most fun here. For other family films, see our Minions & Monsters roundup and Toy Story 5 roundup.
How this was compiled: credits, plot outline, production and box office details come from Warner Bros. and Legendary materials and the trade reporting linked above; critics’ views come from the linked reviews in Consequence, The Independent, The Hollywood Reporter, IGN and Rolling Stone; scores are from Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic and CinemaScore. Bucket Movies did not watch the film for this piece. See how we work.
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
Godzilla Minus Zero Review Roundup: What Critics Said About Takashi Yamazaki's Sequel
Takashi Yamazaki's Godzilla Minus Zero pits Godzilla against King Ghidorah in 1949 Japan. Critics praised its effects and scale and debated whether it tops Minus One. Reviews, production, box office.
Mayday Review: Reynolds and Branagh Make a Cold War Buddy Movie Work
Apple TV's Mayday premieres September 4. Ryan Reynolds and Kenneth Branagh sell a silly Siberian escape better than the stealth-jet premise deserves.
The Burning Sea Review Roundup: Norway's Oil-Rig Disaster Film, Reconsidered
John Andreas Andersen's The Burning Sea (Nordsjøen), a 2021 Norwegian oil-rig disaster film from the team behind The Wave and The Quake. What critics praised, what they faulted, and why it still matters.
Coyote vs. Acme (2026): The Looney Tunes Courtroom Comedy That Refused to Die
Coyote vs. Acme, the Looney Tunes courtroom comedy Warner Bros. shelved for a tax write-off, finally reached theaters in 2026. What critics said, how it was made, how it was saved, and how it performed.




Loading comments...