The Rivals of Amziah King Review Roundup: What Critics Said About Andrew Patterson's Honey Noir
Andrew Patterson's neo-Western about an Oklahoma beekeeper, starring Matthew McConaughey and newcomer Angelina LookingGlass, drew strong reviews. What critics praised, the dissents, and how it was made.
Editor’s note: This review is a roundup of published critical reception and reporting, with analysis by the Bucket Movies Editorial Team. We did not attend a screening; plot and scene details are summarized from published reviews and official materials. See how we work.
Editor’s note: an earlier version of this article described scenes and offered first-person judgments that could not be matched to a source. It has been rewritten from the published reviews and reporting linked below.
Our angle: The Rivals of Amziah King was sold as Matthew McConaughey’s return to the screen. Nearly every review pointed out that it is really a showcase for a newcomer, Angelina LookingGlass, and that the film changes genre partway through. This roundup sets out how critics responded to that switch.
What the film is
The Rivals of Amziah King is an American neo-Western black comedy written and directed by Andrew Patterson, whose debut, The Vast of Night (2019), was a festival and streaming discovery. Patterson is credited under the pseudonym James Montague for writing and producing. McConaughey plays Amziah King, an Oklahoma beekeeper, bluegrass musician and community anchor. LookingGlass, in her film debut, plays Kateri, his former foster daughter. Kurt Russell plays the wealthy rival Dob McCoy, with Rob Morgan, Scott Shepherd, Owen Teague, Tony Revolori, Jake Horowitz and Cole Sprouse in support. Black Bear Pictures and Heyday Films produced. The film premiered at SXSW on March 10, 2025, and Black Bear released it in U.S. theaters on August 14, 2026. It runs about two hours and ten minutes.
The premise (no ending)
Amziah reconnects with Kateri, whom he and his late wife fostered as a child, after he finds her working in a local diner. He takes her into his circle of musicians, neighbors and church potlucks and starts teaching her the honey business, which is buried in debt partly because of his generosity. When Amziah’s hives are stolen, the story shifts to Kateri and to what she is prepared to do about the people responsible. We will not go further than that.
How it was made
- The long road. Patterson had been developing the film since 2020. It was announced in May 2023 with McConaughey attached and Black Bear financing. David Canfield’s making-of feature in The Hollywood Reporter says McConaughey had not shot a live-action film in five years. It quotes him: “I chose this in place of other movies I could have done for a whole lot more money.” In the same piece, Patterson says Denzel Washington read the script and “really loved it” before McConaughey was available, but wanted creative control that Patterson “didn’t see a way around in the narrative.”
- Casting. Russell, Sprouse and others were confirmed alongside McConaughey. To find Kateri, Patterson told THR, the Native American casting director Angelique Midthunder “probably sought out 200, 300 young women.” The Fort Worth Report notes that she is a member of the Oglala Lakota, Navajo, Seneca and Kiowa Comanche tribes and trained at the Stella Adler Conservatory.
- The shoot. Filming took place in Alabama in summer 2023, standing in for Oklahoma. It went ahead during the SAG-AFTRA strike under an interim agreement and wrapped that August. The Fort Worth Report says a scene in which McConaughey is covered in thousands of bees used real bees, with beekeepers on set, and no CGI.
- The conditions. Patterson told THR that the production was “always around bees” and “always getting shut down for lightning strikes and weather,” and that the result is “this big, bright, sunny movie.” The film then spent almost three years between the end of filming and its theatrical release. Patterson discussed the film’s world in an interview with In Review Online.
- The release. In August 2025, Black Bear said it would release the film itself through its new U.S. distribution arm.
What critics praised
Rotten Tomatoes lists 88% approval from more than 100 reviews. Its consensus calls the film “a sprawling, unpredictable, and genre-blurring epic, anchored by Matthew McConaughey’s charm and Angelina LookingGlass’s striking debut.” Metacritic shows 74 from 22 critics, which it classifies as “generally favorable.”
- William Bibbiani of TheWrap called it a “genre-defying wonder.” He argued that “this isn’t Amziah’s story. It’s Kateri’s story, and it’s the whole town’s story,” and that the film “reserves its judgment” on her choices.
- The Fort Worth Report praised a “multi-layered caper that functions as a deeply rooted character study of the rural South.” It called LookingGlass’s work “one of the best performances of the year.”
- The Los Angeles Times described the film’s turn from “wild, wacky — but intentional — world-building into a sleek Southern noir.” In its reading, McConaughey “hands off the film” to LookingGlass.
- Ryan Lattanzio of IndieWire concluded that “Patterson’s big swings in filmmaking transcend the occasional shakier sum of their parts.” He also noted McConaughey “going all in on a character in ways he rarely has in years.”
The hive metaphor
Several critics noticed how thoroughly the film builds on its beekeeping setting. The Los Angeles Times pointed to a scene in which Amziah explains the roles in a hive (drones, workers and the queen) to Kateri. It treated that moment as the hinge where the film turns from comedy to noir. TheWrap extended the image to the whole ensemble: “They behave like a beehive but every drone and worker is unique, and no two queens rule the same way.” IndieWire singled out Owen Teague’s wordless performance leading Amziah’s bluegrass band, and noted that in the film the bees do not sting Kateri, “making his estranged daughter something of a miracle.” AP, more skeptical, described McConaughey’s “pure Cheshire Cat smile, rascally wink and buttery, Southern gentlemanly charm.”
Reservations
- Too much at once. The Associated Press review, headlined “Honey doesn’t make it sweet,” called the film “a maddening mishmash of genres.” It listed “Quentin Tarantino’s sudden brutality, a coming-of-age tale, a heist flick, a revenge fantasy and a sweet, music-filled country hoedown.”
- Style over performance. Even IndieWire’s positive review complained of “over-direction.” Lattanzio wrote that the bluegrass band scenes are sometimes cut “more like a music video than a movie.” He found LookingGlass’s performance “fine-enough” but at times “under-directed,” and said Patterson “never quite digs into who she is as a person on her own terms.” He summed up: “There’s too much movie here, but isn’t that better than none at all?”
- Familiar McConaughey. AP described the performance as “Matthew-McConaughey-turned-up-to-11 mode.” IndieWire, while enjoying it, said his “sweaty swagger and smarmy charisma feel like only familiar comforts.”
So critics broadly agree on what the film is: ambitious and overstuffed, and it changes lead and genre halfway through. They disagree on whether that ambition is a strength or a flaw. They also split over LookingGlass, who was praised loudly in some reviews and found under-served in others.
Box office
The film opened with about $1 million in 632 theaters. It finished with about $2.1 million domestically and $4.1 million worldwide, per Box Office Mojo. That is a modest result for a self-distributed specialty film with a major star, and well short of its reviews.
Where it sits in Patterson’s work
The Vast of Night was a low-budget 1950s sci-fi mystery known for long takes and a strong sense of place. Critics found the same traits here. IndieWire observed that each take seems “precisely storyboarded and choreographed” and praised the “vistas of the Oklahoma landscape.” The new film is much bigger, with a large ensemble, a movie star and a multi-genre plot. That is why the debate centers on control. Critics who liked his debut’s precision tended to admire this, while those who wanted more room for the actors felt it was overdesigned.
Who it is for
Viewers who enjoy rural crime stories with eccentric ensembles, and who don’t mind a long, tonally shifting film, are the most natural audience. McConaughey fans should know that, as IndieWire notes, he is “in less than half” of it. Viewers who prefer a single clear genre may side with AP. The film is rated R. For more Westerns, see our look at the spaghetti Western The Big Gundown, or browse the reviews section.
Our read
The reviews describe a film whose biggest strength is also its biggest risk. It hands a star vehicle to an unknown halfway through, and moves from folk comedy to revenge noir. Most critics thought the swing paid off, and nearly all agreed that LookingGlass is a discovery worth watching. Judged by reviews, it is one of the year’s better-received independent films; judged by box office, it is one few people saw in theaters.
How this was compiled: credits, plot outline, production and release details come from Black Bear materials and the trade coverage linked above; critics’ quotes come from the linked reviews by TheWrap, the Fort Worth Report, the Los Angeles Times, IndieWire and the Associated Press; scores are from Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic; box office from Box Office Mojo. Bucket Movies did not watch the film for this piece. See how we work.
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
Mayday Review: Reynolds and Branagh Make a Cold War Buddy Movie Work
Apple TV's Mayday premieres September 4. Ryan Reynolds and Kenneth Branagh sell a silly Siberian escape better than the stealth-jet premise deserves.
Mutiny (2026) Review Roundup: Jason Statham's Cargo-Ship Thriller Splits Critics Down the Middle
Jean-François Richet's Mutiny puts Jason Statham on a cargo ship against a human-trafficking crew. Critics split almost exactly 50/50. What they praised, what they faulted, and how it performed.
Godzilla Minus Zero Review Roundup: What Critics Said About Takashi Yamazaki's Sequel
Takashi Yamazaki's Godzilla Minus Zero pits Godzilla against King Ghidorah in 1949 Japan. Critics praised its effects and scale and debated whether it tops Minus One. Reviews, production, box office.
The Burning Sea Review Roundup: Norway's Oil-Rig Disaster Film, Reconsidered
John Andreas Andersen's The Burning Sea (Nordsjøen), a 2021 Norwegian oil-rig disaster film from the team behind The Wave and The Quake. What critics praised, what they faulted, and why it still matters.




Loading comments...