The Brutalist movie poster featuring Adrien Brody
The Brutalist movie poster featuring Adrien Brody
Review 8 min read ✓ seen it!

The Brutalist: A Monumental Achievement in Contemporary Cinema

Brady Corbet's 215-minute VistaVision epic about a Hungarian-Jewish architect in postwar Pennsylvania: what critics praised, where they dissented, the AI-dialogue controversy and how it was made.

By Bucket Movies Editorial Team

Editor’s note: This review is a roundup of published critical reception and reporting, with analysis by the Bucket Movies Editorial Team. We did not attend a screening; plot and scene details are summarized from published reviews and official materials. See how we work.

Our angle: The Brutalist is often discussed as a feat of scale, with its 215-minute running time, its VistaVision photography and its intermission. This piece focuses on a smaller fact that explains much of the reaction, which is that a film this large was made for under $10 million in 34 days. It then sets out what the leading reviews argued, for and against.

What The Brutalist is

The Brutalist is a 2024 period drama directed by Brady Corbet, who co-wrote it with his partner Mona Fastvold; the two had previously written The Childhood of a Leader (2015) and Vox Lux (2018) together. Adrien Brody stars as László Tóth, a fictional Hungarian-Jewish Holocaust survivor and Bauhaus-trained architect who emigrates to the United States. Felicity Jones plays his wife, Erzsébet, and Guy Pearce plays Harrison Lee Van Buren, the wealthy Pennsylvania industrialist who becomes his patron. Joe Alwyn, Raffey Cassidy, Stacy Martin, Emma Laird, Isaach de Bankolé and Alessandro Nivola co-star.

The film premiered at the 81st Venice International Film Festival on September 1, 2024, where Corbet won the Silver Lion for Best Direction. A24 released it in the United States on December 20, 2024. It runs 215 minutes including an intermission, which Corbet discussed with Variety before the premiere.

The story, in outline

The film is divided into an overture, two parts and an epilogue. László arrives in New York after being separated from Erzsébet and his orphaned niece, Zsófia, and goes to Philadelphia in 1947 to stay with his cousin Attila (Nivola), who has anglicized his name and converted to Catholicism. A commission to renovate a library at the Van Buren mansion near Doylestown goes badly. Three years later, László, now addicted to heroin, is loading coal when Harrison reappears: the library has been praised by the architecture press, and he wants László to design a grand community institute in memory of his mother.

The second part begins in 1953, when Erzsébet and Zsófia finally arrive. Erzsébet uses a wheelchair because of osteoporosis caused by wartime starvation, and Zsófia no longer speaks. The institute’s construction becomes a long struggle over money, control and the Van Burens’ contempt for the people they employ. We leave the outline there. The film’s later turns and its 1980 epilogue at the Venice Architecture Biennale are the parts critics discussed most, and they are better met fresh.

How it was made

The production history is unusually well documented, and it explains why reviewers so often mention the film’s craft.

  • A long gestation. Deadline first reported the project in September 2018. In 2020, an earlier cast was announced, led by Joel Edgerton, Marion Cotillard and Mark Rylance. COVID restrictions, the war in Ukraine and several pregnancies and deaths among cast and crew pushed the shoot back. By April 2023 the cast had been replaced, with Brody, Jones and Pearce in the leads.
  • Hungary for Pennsylvania. Principal photography began on March 16, 2023, in Budapest, which doubled as 1950s Philadelphia and rural Pennsylvania. Andrássy Castle in Tóalmás stood in for the Van Buren mansion. The production then shot in the marble quarries of Carrara, Italy, and wrapped after 34 days on May 5, 2023. The Venice epilogue had been shot years earlier, in September 2020.
  • VistaVision. Most of the film was shot in VistaVision, a 1950s format that runs 35mm film horizontally through the camera. Corbet said the best way to access the decade was to use a format “engineered in that same decade.” Cinematographer Lol Crawley said its wider field of view let him photograph architecture without distorting wide-angle lenses. The production also struck 70mm prints.
  • The budget. Corbet put the net budget at $9.6 million in a Le Cinéma Club Q&A. The film grossed about $50.4 million worldwide.
  • The building. Production designer Judy Becker designed the Van Buren Institute, which was built only in parts and as a scale model. Her references included Marcel Breuer, Tadao Ando, Louis Kahn’s Salk Institute and James Turrell’s skyspaces.

Box office

A24 released the film gradually. It opened on December 20, 2024, with $266,791 from four U.S. theaters, then held at a little over $200,000 for two more weekends before expanding to 68 theaters and $1.38 million. After its ten Oscar nominations, it moved to 1,118 theaters and took $2.9 million in a weekend. It finished at about $16.3 million in the U.S. and Canada and $34.1 million internationally, roughly five times its net budget.

The AI controversy

In January 2025, editor Dávid Jancsó told RedShark News that software from the Ukrainian company Respeecher had been used to refine Brody’s and Jones’s Hungarian-language dialogue. The comments caused a backlash during awards season. Corbet responded in a statement to Deadline that the actors’ “performances are completely their own.” He said the tool was used “in Hungarian language dialogue editing only, specifically to refine certain vowels and letters for accuracy,” and that “no English language was changed.” He also denied that AI had been used to design the film’s buildings, saying all images were hand-drawn. The exception, he explained, was a memorial video in the epilogue whose images were deliberately made to look like crude digital renderings from around 1980.

What critics praised

Rotten Tomatoes reports a 93% approval rating from more than 330 reviews. Its summary calls the film “structurally beautiful and suffused with Adrien Brody’s soulful performance,” a “towering tribute to the immigrant experience.” Metacritic lists a score of 90.

Peter Bradshaw of The Guardian gave it five stars, calling it “an amazing and engrossing epic” that draws on Ayn Rand, Bernard Malamud and Saul Bellow. He praised Crawley’s cinematography and Becker’s design and said he left “light-headed and euphoric.” Owen Gleiberman of Variety found it “paced with a pleasing stateliness” despite its length. He compared Brody’s performance to his Oscar-winning role in The Pianist (2002), writing that it is “suffused with tumultuous feeling” even at its quietest, and said Pearce had not “popped in a role” like this in a long time.

Brian Tallerico of RogerEbert.com gave it four stars, describing a film that winds “its themes around its characters like a great American novel.” He called Brody’s work “the best work of his career” and the film “a technical marvel.” RogerEbert.com’s writers later placed it at the top of the site’s ten best films of 2024.

Where critics dissented

Even admirers had reservations. Tallerico found Jones “a bit miscast.” David Sims of The Atlantic read the film as Corbet’s “grand canvas to explore his own frustrations with the limits that commerce places on the arts” and praised Brody’s “pained and lived-in” performance. But he called the second half “something of a slog,” “unrelenting in its despair.”

Richard Brody of The New Yorker was the most prominent dissenter, arguing under the headline “The Empty Ambition of The Brutalist” that the epic “takes on weighty themes, but fails to infuse its characters with the stuff of life.”

The pattern is consistent: critics broadly agree about the craft and Brody’s performance, and disagree about the second half, the film’s treatment of its female characters and whether its ambition is matched by its drama.

Awards and influence

The Brutalist received ten nominations at the 97th Academy Awards, including Best Picture, Best Director and acting nominations for Brody, Jones and Pearce. It won three Oscars: Best Actor for Brody (his second, 22 years after The Pianist), Best Cinematography for Crawley and Best Original Score for Daniel Blumberg. At the Golden Globes it won Best Motion Picture – Drama, Best Director and Best Actor in a Drama.

Its most practical legacy may be technical. The film’s use of VistaVision revived industry interest in the format, which was later used for Paul Thomas Anderson’s One Battle After Another (see our review), Yorgos Lanthimos’s Bugonia and Alejandro González Iñárritu’s Digger.

Who it is for

The reviews suggest a clear audience: viewers who enjoy long-form American epics in the tradition of There Will Be Blood or The Godfather Part II, people interested in architecture and postwar immigration, and anyone curious about large-format film. Viewers who share Sims’s and Richard Brody’s reservations about the second half may find the intermission a natural stopping point.

For another 2024 awards contender, see our Anora review, or browse the reviews section.

How this was compiled: credits, plot outline, production history and awards come from the film’s documented production record and the linked trade coverage in Deadline and Variety; the budget figure is from Corbet’s Le Cinéma Club interview; critics’ quotes come from the linked reviews in The Guardian, Variety, RogerEbert.com, The Atlantic and The New Yorker; scores are from Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic. Bucket Movies did not watch the film for this piece. See how we work.

Filed under #The Brutalist #Brady Corbet #Adrien Brody #2024 films
Pass it on a friend needs this film
0 reads0 comments

worth a spot on the list?

Reader notes

Join the discussion

No account needed — leave your take on this film below.

0/1000

Loading comments...

Up next

Add these to your list

More review