Other Mommy Box Office: How an $18 Million Horror Film Won October Despite Bad Reviews
Universal and Blumhouse-Atomic Monster's Other Mommy, starring Jessica Chastain and directed by Rob Savage, opened at No. 1 with $27.5 million and passed $115 million worldwide despite a D+ CinemaScore. What it's about, how the run unfolded, and what it says about horror economics.
Other Mommy opened in North American theaters on October 9, 2026, and became one of the most profitable releases of the fall despite some of the worst reviews and audience scores of any wide release this year. This report was first published on opening weekend and has been updated through November 8.
Our angle: Other Mommy is a clean example of how the low-budget horror model works, including its weak point. It shows how a film can be a hit without being liked.
The opening
The first numbers were encouraging. Variety reported $3.6 million from Thursday previews on 2,850 screens, with weekend projections of $22 million to $28 million and some industry estimates going higher.
The film
Other Mommy is a Universal release from Blumhouse and James Wan’s Atomic Monster, directed by Rob Savage and starring Jessica Chastain, with Jay Duplass as her husband and Dichen Lachman, Arian Moayed and Karen Allen in supporting roles. Nathan Elston’s screenplay adapts Josh Malerman’s 2024 novel Incidents Around the House; Malerman is also the author of Bird Box. The film was shot in Dublin beginning in May 2025 and runs 93 minutes. According to Variety’s preview, the story follows a seven-year-old girl visited by a supernatural entity that takes on the appearance of her mother — a premise that taps into one of horror’s most primal fears and recalls Coraline’s “Other Mother” and the identity horror of Goodnight Mommy.
Chastain’s casting gives the film a star unusually prominent for a Blumhouse production.
Why the budget matters
Variety reported a production budget of about $18 million. That’s the Blumhouse model in action: keep costs low so a film can be profitable even on a modest opening. Pre-weekend tracking from Variety and Deadline put the opening around $20 million — already more than the production cost before marketing. Variety also expected it to unseat the previous weekend’s leader, Verity.
How it compares
Preview grosses of a few million dollars are typical for successful original horror. As a reference, 2022’s Smile earned $2 million in previews and opened to $22.6 million before a long run. Other Mommy’s higher preview figure suggests a stronger start, and an October release date gives it a natural runway through Halloween.
The competition
The weekend’s other new wide release was Sony’s The Social Reckoning, Aaron Sorkin’s drama about a Facebook whistleblower, which made $650,000 in previews per Variety. The two films target very different audiences, which is usually good news for theaters. In the end, the counter-programming only worked one way. The Social Reckoning opened fifth with about $5.5 million, well below forecasts, and fell 69% in its second weekend. Deadline later reported that the Sorkin film cost $30 million to $42 million and that Alcon co-financed half, which limited Sony’s losses. The contrast is instructive: an adult drama with strong pedigree and a big subject could not find an audience, while a cheap horror film with poor reviews could, because horror audiences show up for the concept before the verdict is in.
The “evil double” tradition
Other Mommy’s premise — something that looks exactly like a parent but isn’t — draws on one of the oldest fears in horror and folklore. European changeling myths told of fairies swapping a child for an impostor; Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956) turned the idea into Cold War paranoia, with neighbours replaced by emotionless copies. More recent films have made the threat specifically parental: Neil Gaiman’s Coraline, adapted by Henry Selick in 2009, gave children the button-eyed “Other Mother,” and the Austrian thriller Goodnight Mommy (2014) built its tension around twins who suspect the bandaged woman at home is not their mother. Jordan Peele’s Us (2019) took the doppelgänger idea in a social direction.
That lineage helps explain the film’s marketing appeal. The concept can be understood from a single image, it plays on a fear nearly every viewer recognises, and it gives a star like Jessica Chastain the chance to play both warmth and menace.
The filmmakers
Rob Savage made his name with Host (2020), an hour-long horror film set entirely on a Zoom call and shot during the first pandemic lockdown, which became a word-of-mouth hit on the streaming service Shudder. He followed it with Dashcam (2021) and the Stephen King adaptation The Boogeyman (2023), which earned more than $80 million worldwide on a modest budget.
Producer James Wan co-created both Saw and The Conjuring universe, and his company Atomic Monster merged with Jason Blum’s Blumhouse in 2024. The combined company has become the dominant supplier of mid-budget studio horror, with a business model built on keeping costs low and releasing frequently.
How the run unfolded
Other Mommy opened at No. 1 with about $27.5 million from 3,365 theaters, at the top of its projected range, with $12.6 million on Friday alone (Deadline). It beat Verity’s second weekend ($11.5 million) by more than double, and the overall market was up about 18.5% on the same weekend in 2025. Deadline noted that Hurricane Isaias, which made landfall on the Gulf Coast that Friday, dented business in the South.
Then the reviews and word of mouth caught up. Audiences gave the film a D+ CinemaScore, and only 33% of PostTrak respondents said they would definitely recommend it. The second weekend fell about 70% to roughly $8.2 million, one of the steepest drops of the fall for a No. 1 opener. The third weekend fell another 53% to about $3.85 million, for a domestic total of about $51.5 million (Deadline).
Even so, the arithmetic works. By November 8 the film had grossed about $58.3 million in the U.S. and Canada and about $57 million internationally, roughly $115 million worldwide against an $18 million to $19 million budget. That is more than six times its production cost, before marketing.
What critics said
Critics were harsh. Rotten Tomatoes listed a 19% approval rating from about 100 reviews, with a consensus that credited “a valiant turn from Jessica Chastain” but found the film “too silly for its intermittently effective jump scares to add up to a spooky whole.” Metacritic’s average was 39. The New York Times called it a “sometimes-creepy, sometimes-hilarious schlockfest,” and Benjamin Lee in The Guardian gave it two stars, describing a tense opening that turns into an “increasingly absurd battle with a special effects oogum-boogum.”
A hit without fans
The gap between the box office and the reception is the real story. Horror’s opening weekends are driven by concept and marketing, and Other Mommy had both: a premise you can grasp from one image, a recognizable star, and a release date that put it at the front of the Halloween season. Reviews and CinemaScore matter much more for the second and third weekends, and those weekends collapsed. Because the budget was so low, the front-loaded run was still enough.
The risk in this model is cumulative. A string of poorly received horror films can wear down the trust that makes audiences turn out on opening night. Blumhouse’s best years came from films that were both cheap and well liked, such as Get Out and M3GAN. Other Mommy is cheap and profitable, but it is not the kind of film that builds a brand. For Rob Savage, though, it is a second commercial success in a row after The Boogeyman, and that track record is what studios hire for.
Who should see it
- Horror fans who enjoy psychological, domestic horror more than gore.
- Parents may find it especially unnerving; it plays directly on the fear of a family being invaded from within.
- Younger viewers should check the rating and content advisories first — the subject matter is designed to frighten.
What preview numbers tell you
Thursday previews — screenings that begin the evening before a film’s official Friday release — have become the earliest public indicator of a film’s opening. Analysts compare them with similar films to estimate the weekend. Horror films tend to have a high ratio of previews to total weekend, because fans are eager to see them first, while family films earn more of their money on Saturday and Sunday. A $3.6 million preview for a horror film typically suggests an opening several times larger, which is roughly what happened here.
Blumhouse’s recent run
Blumhouse’s track record includes Get Out (2017), which won the Oscar for Original Screenplay, the Purge and Insidious series, M3GAN (2022) and Five Nights at Freddy’s (2023). It has also had misfires, including The Exorcist: Believer (2023), which underperformed expectations for a planned trilogy. The company’s model allows for this: many small bets, a few big hits.
Sources
Preview and weekend figures come from the trade reports linked above, and Screendollars’ 2026 weekly totals are a useful cross-check. Figures are studio estimates and are subject to revision. Reviews are summarized from published criticism; Bucket Movies did not attend a screening. See how we work.
For the chart around its opening, see our weekend box office report, and for its third weekend, our October 23-25 report.
worth a spot on the list?
Reader notes
Join the discussion
No account needed — leave your take on this film below.
Add these to your list
Clayface Box Office: DC's $24.5 Million Horror Experiment, Explained
Clayface opened at No. 1 with about $24.5 million in North America and $43 million worldwide. How the weekend unfolded, how it compares with DC and horror openings, and what the holds since then say about DC's mid-budget gamble.
Play House: Why a $100,000 Horror Film Sold to Focus and Blumhouse
Focus Features and Blumhouse-Atomic Monster bought Nicolas Curcio's micro-budget horror film Play House in a seven-figure deal. What the film is about, how a pitch contest got it made, and what the sale says about low-budget horror.
Other Mommy Tops the Box Office as 2026 Passes $8 Billion Domestic
Universal's Other Mommy opened to an estimated $27.5 million as the 2026 domestic box office crossed $8 billion. What the milestone means for theaters and how this year compares with 2019.
Weekend Box Office (Oct. 23–25): Clayface Wins, but You Can See Everything Steals the Story
Clayface opened at No. 1 with about $24.5 million, while Nathan Fielder's Elizabeth Holmes documentary grew 25% in its second weekend. The full top ten, the holdovers, what happened the following weekend and what it all means.




Loading comments...