An almost empty movie theater in warm dim light, red seats, and a face-down ticket stub with no readable text.
An almost empty movie theater in warm dim light, red seats, and a face-down ticket stub with no readable text.
News 8 min read ✓ seen it!

Verity Opens to $32 Million While Tom Cruise's Digger Stumbles: What Happened

Colleen Hoover adaptation Verity opened at No. 1 with $32 million despite weak reviews, while Tom Cruise and Alejandro G. Iñárritu's satire Digger debuted to $8 million on a budget of up to $180 million. Why audiences chose differently.

By Bucket Movies Editorial Team

The first weekend of October 2026 produced one of the year’s starkest contrasts. According to Variety, Amazon MGM’s Verity opened at No. 1 with $32.6 million from 3,510 theaters, while Warner Bros.’ Digger, starring Tom Cruise, debuted to just $8 million from 3,321 theaters and finished fifth. Deadline noted it was Cruise’s lowest opening in 19 years.

Our angle: both films drew poor audience scores (each earned a C+ CinemaScore), so word of mouth does not explain the gap. The difference was cost and a pre-sold audience. One film was cheap and aimed at millions of readers; the other was expensive and had to persuade a general audience to try an unusual satire.

Verity: a hit despite the reviews

Verity, directed by Michael Showalter (The Big Sick) from a screenplay by Nick Antosca, adapts Colleen Hoover’s best-selling 2018 psychological thriller. Dakota Johnson plays Lowen Ashleigh, a struggling writer hired to finish the popular book series of Verity Crawford (Anne Hathaway), a famous author left badly injured after a car accident. Josh Hartnett plays Verity’s husband, Jeremy. As David A. Gross of FranchiseRe summarises, the writer discovers a hidden manuscript and becomes involved with the husband. The film runs 117 minutes.

Critics were unimpressed. Variety cited a 34% Rotten Tomatoes score at opening and a C+ CinemaScore; by November, Rotten Tomatoes showed 32% from about 190 reviews and Metacritic a score of 44. The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw liked the premise but felt the story “disintegrates” in its final act. Gross nonetheless called the opening excellent: “The reception is not hurting the film. Audiences are showing up in big numbers.”

The audience explains why. Variety reported that opening-weekend crowds were 78% female, and the largest age group (38%) was 25 to 34. Hoover’s books have a huge, devoted readership, and book fans buy tickets to see the story they already love. The economics also helped: Variety put the production budget at $40 million, and the film was expected to turn a profit. It also added about $30 million internationally in its first weekend, for a $62.5 million global start, and it was Hathaway’s third No. 1 opening of 2026 after The Devil Wears Prada 2 and The Odyssey.

Digger: a costly miss

Digger pairs Cruise with director Alejandro G. Iñárritu (Birdman, The Revenant). It is not the awards drama its pedigree suggested but an R-rated satirical black comedy: Cruise plays Digger Rockwell, an aging oil tycoon whose drilling in Greenland sets off an ecological disaster, and the story is framed by a stage production of the same events. Riz Ahmed, John Goodman, Sandra Hüller, Michael Stuhlbarg and Jesse Plemons co-star, and Emmanuel Lubezki, Iñárritu’s longtime cinematographer, shot it in the U.K.

Variety reported that Warner Bros. greenlit the film at $125 million, that the cost rose to $160 to $180 million after production ran long, and that the studio spent about $100 million more on marketing. It estimated a theatrical break-even point of roughly $350 million worldwide; a Warner Bros. spokesperson put it at $300 million. Studio hopes for an $18 million to $20 million opening had been revised down after poor buzz, and the international start of $12 million from 73 markets was no better. “For a black comedy, the numbers are not bad,” Gross told Variety. “But black comedies are small films, and this isn’t a small film. It’s a Tom Cruise movie.”

Reviews were genuinely split, as The Hollywood Reporter documented: some critics called it “insufferable,” others “terrific.” Rotten Tomatoes settled around 52% and Metacritic at 46. Deadline also blamed trailers that left audiences unsure of the film’s tone and plot. We covered the awards side in our look at Cruise’s Oscar campaign. By early November, Wikipedia’s tally of The Numbers data put the worldwide gross at about $50 million, a small fraction of the break-even estimate.

The timing was also poor for the studio. Digger was Warner Bros.’ last release before Paramount Skydance’s acquisition of the company closed on October 6, and Variety noted that none of the studio’s 2026 films had crossed $100 million domestically by that weekend.

The rest of the top five

Variety’s report placed Sony’s Resident Evil, directed by Zach Cregger, second in its third weekend with $12.5 million, bringing its domestic total to $124.8 million against a $75 million budget. Paramount’s Brad Pitt survival thriller Heart of the Beast was third with $11 million in its second weekend, and A24’s Primetime, with Robert Pattinson as Chris Hansen, was fourth with $8 million. Overall, the domestic box office stood at $7.95 billion for the year, up 19% from the same point in 2025, according to Rentrak.

What the weekend tells us

  • Pre-sold audiences beat reviews. For adaptations with a passionate fan base, critical reception matters less than it does for original films.
  • Budget decides what counts as a flop. Both films received a C+ CinemaScore; one cost $40 million and the other up to four times that.
  • Star power has limits. Even the biggest movie star struggles when the genre doesn’t match what audiences expect from him.
  • Women remain an underserved audience. Films aimed at women continue to over-perform, as our summer box office analysis also found.

The Colleen Hoover effect

Colleen Hoover became one of the best-selling authors in the U.S. in the early 2020s, helped enormously by BookTok, the reading community on TikTok. Verity (2018), originally self-published, is her most popular thriller. Variety’s comparison puts Verity second among Hoover adaptations by opening weekend, behind It Ends With Us (2024), which opened to $50 million and grossed about $350 million worldwide despite mixed reviews and a much-publicised dispute between its stars. It is ahead of Regretting You (2025, $13.6 million) and Reminders of Him (2026, $17 million).

Michael Showalter, the director, is better known for warm comedies such as The Big Sick (2017) and The Lovebirds (2020), and for directing The Eyes of Tammy Faye (2021), which won Jessica Chastain the Best Actress Oscar.

Why Digger struggled

Tom Cruise’s recent films have mostly been large franchise entries: Top Gun: Maverick (2022) earned nearly $1.5 billion worldwide. Digger was, as Variety put it, “the rare big-budget, star-driven R-rated original comedy,” and Cruise’s first-dollar gross deal means he is paid from revenue before the studio recoups. Original star-driven films face a tougher market, and Variety’s analysts said a film of this cost would have needed a debut near $40 million to justify itself.

Alejandro G. Iñárritu’s track record

Iñárritu is one of the most decorated filmmakers of his generation. He won back-to-back Best Director Oscars for Birdman (2014), which also won Best Picture, and The Revenant (2015), which earned Leonardo DiCaprio his first Oscar. His earlier work, including Amores perros (2000), 21 Grams (2003) and Babel (2006), built his reputation for intense, interlocking dramas. His most recent film before Digger, Bardo, False Chronicle of a Handful of Truths (2022), was released by Netflix after a short theatrical run.

That pedigree makes the opening more striking. Prestige directors working with major stars do not always translate into opening-weekend audiences; Killers of the Flower Moon (2023), for example, opened to about $23 million despite Martin Scorsese and Leonardo DiCaprio, and found much of its audience later on Apple TV.

Comparing the two films’ audiences

Verity and Digger illustrate two different kinds of moviegoing. Verity is a pre-sold adaptation with a huge reader base, many of them younger women who discovered the book online, and that kind of audience turns out quickly on opening weekend. Digger depended on star appeal, curiosity and reviews, which typically build more slowly. Opening weekend measures the first kind of demand well and the second badly. In this case, though, the later weeks did not close the gap: Digger’s polarized reviews and C+ CinemaScore gave it little word of mouth to build on, while Verity kept drawing its core audience for several more weekends.

How the weeks after went

Verity fell 63% to about $12 million in its second weekend, finishing second behind Other Mommy; see our weekend report. By November 8 it had grossed about $76 million domestically and $179 million worldwide, according to Box Office Mojo and The Numbers, a clear success on a $40 million budget. Digger dropped 60% to $3.2 million in its second weekend and had grossed about $18 million domestically by early November.

Should you see them?

  • Verity is for Hoover fans and anyone who enjoys twisty, melodramatic thrillers; note that it deals with violence and adult themes, and temper expectations given the reviews.
  • Digger is for viewers curious about Iñárritu’s ambitious, divisive filmmaking and a very different Cruise role; it may find more appreciation at home.

How this was compiled: weekend figures, budgets and audience data come from Variety’s and Deadline’s reports; later totals and review scores come from Box Office Mojo, The Numbers and the aggregator pages linked above. Bucket Movies did not watch either film. See how we work.

Filed under #Verity #Digger #box office #Tom Cruise #Colleen Hoover
Pass it on a friend needs this film
0 reads0 comments

worth a spot on the list?

Reader notes

Join the discussion

No account needed — leave your take on this film below.

0/1000

Loading comments...

Up next

Add these to your list

More news